ActiveCampaign vs Mailchimp vs Aweber vs GetResponse – My Experience Finding the Best Email Service

4/5 - (2 votes)

It all started when I launched my online business selling handmade jewelry. I knew I needed to set up some type of email marketing to connect with potential customers, share news and promotions, and build my audience. But with so many options out there, how was I supposed to choose the right email service provider?

1. Getting Started with Research

Being the diligent entrepreneur that I am, I rolled up my sleeves and started researching the top email marketing services. I looked at reviews, compared pricing and features, and signed up for free trials. After testing out several different platforms, I narrowed it down to the big four contenders:

  • ActiveCampaign
  • Mailchimp
  • Aweber
  • GetResponse

All four seemed to have solid reputations and good core email marketing features. However, I knew the best option for me depended on the specifics of my business and goals.

2. Evaluating Based on My Needs

As a solopreneur selling handmade products online, my main priorities were:

  • Easy-to-use interface
  • Attractive email templates
  • Ability to integrate with my e-commerce platform
  • Analytics to track engagement
  • Affordable pricing for small lists

I carefully compared each platform based on these criteria, creating test emails and tinkering with the dashboards. After a few weeks of rigorous testing, I finally decided on the winner for my business.

3. The Verdict: Going with ActiveCampaign

ActiveCampaign came out on top as the best email service provider for my needs for several reasons:

User-Friendly Interface

Of all the platforms, ActiveCampaign had the most intuitive interface. The dashboard layout was clean and easy to navigate. I was able to quickly create emails, view reports, and access settings without hassle.

Beautiful Templates

I wanted my emails to represent my elegant jewelry brand, so having professional, customizable templates was key. ActiveCampaign offers hundreds of templates that can be customized with my images, colors, and text.

E-commerce Integration

Since my store is on Shopify, I needed an email platform that integrates seamlessly. ActiveCampaign has a Shopify app that connects in just a few clicks.

Helpful Analytics

Understanding my email performance is critical. ActiveCampaign provides detailed analytics on opens, clicks, and conversions so I can optimize my efforts.

Affordable Pricing

As a small business, cost was a big factor. ActiveCampaign has affordable plans (Activecampaign Lite vs Plus) starting at just $9 per month for 500 contacts. Volume discounts make it very budget-friendly.

By meeting all my needs, ActiveCampaign was the clear choice to power my email marketing and take my business to the next level.


Read more details about Activecampaign coupon code here

4. How the Other Platforms Compare

While ActiveCampaign was the right fit for me, the other platforms each have unique strengths that may match other use cases:

4.1 Mailchimp

Mailchimp is arguably the most well-known email marketing platform, used by millions of businesses. It’s known for its ease of use and generous free plan that allows you to get started with email marketing at no cost.

Some key strengths of Mailchimp:

  • Extremely simple drag-and-drop editor that’s very intuitive even for beginners.
  • Pre-designed email templates that look nice and can be customized.
  • Automation for emails like welcome sequences, though not as complex as other platforms.
  • Decent analytics on opens, clicks, etc to see email performance.
  • The free plan allows up to 2,000 contacts and basic features.

The biggest downside of Mailchimp is the limitations for more advanced users. Once you reach the limits of their automation and integrations, you may need to upgrade to a paid plan which can get more expensive at higher tiers.

Overall Mailchimp is best suited for solopreneurs, side hustlers, and small teams just getting started with email marketing and growing their first audience. It likely won’t scale as well for mid-size or larger businesses.

4.2 Aweber

Aweber has been around for over 20 years and has a reputation for sophisticated automation features. For growing businesses, it can provide very powerful email marketing capabilities.

Here are some of Aweber’s notable features:

  • Segmentation tags and lists for highly targeted groups.
  • Automation workflows with complex conditional logic.
  • Lead scoring to identify and track engaged subscribers.
  • Integration with many membership platforms.
  • Decent template customization.
  • Analytics on email and list performance.

Potential downsides of Aweber are its less user-friendly interface compared to newer platforms, as well as more limited template designs. It also does not integrate quite as deeply with mainstream e-commerce platforms like Shopify.

For businesses wanting to level up beyond basic email into more advanced behavioral targeting and complex automation, Aweber is a leading choice. But it may feel clunky for users who prefer simplicity.

4.3 GetResponse

GetResponse differentiates itself by combining email marketing, CRM, and sophisticated marketing automation in one platform. For e-commerce brands, it’s a compelling offering.

Key features of GetResponse include:

  • Powerful CRM for collecting customer data and profiles.
  • Shopping cart integration for real-time email triggers.
  • Automation based on customer behaviors and preferences.
  • Advanced analytics for email and business.
  • Webinars, landing pages, and forms to expand marketing.
  • High deliverability and inboxing rates.

Potential drawbacks are GetResponse’s complexity and steep learning curve. It has a wide array of features that take time to master. The pricing is also on the higher end, so it may not be feasible for early-stage startups.

For established e-commerce businesses ready to take their marketing to the next level, GetResponse is a leading choice due to the depth of its customer data and automation capabilities. But the learning curve is real.

5. A Glance comparison of the key features:

Email EditorDrag & drop, simpleDrag & drop, simpleDecentFairly robust
TemplatesHundreds of customizable templatesGood selectionFairly limitedDecent selection
AutomationsDecent workflow builderBasic automationsVery sophisticatedAdvanced behavioral automations
AnalyticsVery robustGoodFairly robustVery robust
EcommerceShopify, WooCommerce, etcLimited integrationsSome basic integrationsIntegrates with most platforms
Learning CurveEasyVery easyModerateSteep
Starting Price$9/mo for 500 contactsFree up to 2,000$19/mo for 500 contacts$15/mo for 500 contacts

6. Key Takeaways from My Experience

After taking this journey to find the best email service for my small business, here are some key lessons I learned:

  • Take time to thoroughly evaluate platforms based on your specific needs and goals. Don’t assume one size fits all
  • Leverage free trials to actually test out sending emails, using automations, and digging into analytics. See what it’s really like to use.
  • Pay attention to the quality and customizability of templates. Your emails represent your brand.
  • Make sure the platform integrates with the e-commerce platform and other tools you use to avoid headaches.
  • Consider scalability if you plan to grow your list substantially over time.
  • Don’t underestimate the importance of analytics and reporting to improve.

Finding the right email marketing platform took research and patience on my part, but was well worth the effort. ActiveCampaign hit the sweet spot for my handmade jewelry business. I’m thrilled to have an email partner who can help me nurture relationships with subscribers and grow my business for years to come.

7. Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main difference between Mailchimp and ActiveCampaign?

    The main difference is that ActiveCampaign has more advanced features like CRM, marketing automation, and robust analytics, while Mailchimp is better for beginners with very basic email needs.

  2. Does Aweber have templates?

    Yes, Aweber does have templates – but they are more limited in selection and customizability compared to other platforms like ActiveCampaign.

  3. Is GetResponse better for B2B or B2C?

    With its strong CRM features, GetResponse is likely better suited for B2B companies who want deeper customer profiles and Segmentation. It can still work for B2C, but is overkill for many consumer brands.

  4. Which platform is best for a growing small business on a budget?

    For a growing small business on budget, ActiveCampaign is a great choice with its affordable plans starting at $9/month and powerful features to take you to the next level.

  5. What should you do before choosing an email service provider?

    Before choosing a provider, thoroughly research your options, sign up for free trials, test out sending emails and using features, evaluate based on your specific needs and priorities, and compare pricing models for your list size.

  6. Are all these software available in all countries?

    Yes, all these software are available for all countries like United States, South Korea, Russia, India, Brazil, Vietnam, United Kingdom, Canada, Taiwan, Turkey, etc

8. Video Review:

If you are a video person, you can watch this video.